| *Charles H. Humphreys, Sr. | 1922 | *George W. Wise | 1967 | ||
| *Thomas P. Eddowes | 1923 | *Dalton C.H. Tait | 1968 | ||
| *John Barber | 1924 | *Horace Draper | 1969 | ||
| *Harold E. Houseman | 1925 | Roy S. Doan | 1970 | ||
| *Clinton M. Smith | 1926 | *Thomas A. Bartie | 1971 | ||
| *Elwood B. Moyer | 1927 | #Allen R. Wenker | 1972 | ||
| *Silas R. Rhoads | 1928 | *Edmund A. Murphy,Sr. | 1973 | ||
| *Edwin E.Nicholas | 1929 | #Norman S. Clopper | 1974 | ||
| *Robert MacMullen | 1930 | #William C. Clopper,Sr. | 1975 | ||
| *Charles Young | 1931 | *George R. McDowell,Sr. | 1976 | ||
| *Mac R. Gabrio | 1932 | *John F. Jaeger | 1977 | ||
| *George Stein | 1933 | *Donald G. Cornell | 1978 | ||
| *Russell W. Tomlinson | 1934 | John J. Hunt PDDGM - Lodge 52 | 1978 | ||
| *John J. Weiser | 1935 | *Ralph S. Wetzel | 1979 | ||
| *Franklin West | 1936 | *John A. Rebhorn | 1980 | ||
| *Bernard M. Harris | 1937 | Eugene A. Rothenberg - Lodge 591 | 1980 | ||
| *Walter M. Weller | 1938 | 1 George D. Webster | 1981 | ||
| *David K. Arnold | 1939 | *Domenic D. Gazzara | 1982 | ||
| *Quincy L. Bradford | 1940 | Joseph P. Purcell | 1983 | ||
| *William W. Thompson | 1941 | 2 Raymond C. Townsend | 1984 | ||
| *Elmer B. Vansant | 1942 | #Charles M. Wacker | 1985 | ||
| *Franklin C. Spitler | 1943 | *David P. Tomlin | 1986 | ||
| *Eugene C. Gottshall | 1944 | *Henry Nomes, Jr. | 1987 | ||
| *A. Ervin Ivins | 1945 | William Purcell | 1988 | ||
| *William H. Almond | 1946 | Joseph M.Rosen - Lodge 246 | 1988 | ||
| *Robert B. Vansant | 1947 | Allen W. Stackhouse | 1989 | ||
| *George H. Weldon | 1948 | Vincent Risko | 1990 | ||
| *G.E. Rowland Murray | 1949 | Robert L. Price | 1991 | ||
| *Harry J. Upton | 1950 | John F. Groves | 1992 | ||
| *C. Edward Hanson, Jr. | 1951 | *Charles N. Lambing - Lodge 600 | 1992 | ||
| *David T. Reeves | 1952 | Robert J. McGonigle - Lodge 271 | 1992 | ||
| *W. Clifford Slotterback | 1953 | Robert J. McGonigle - Lodge 271 | 1993 | ||
| *C. Leonard DePue | 1954 | Max H. Starke | 1993 | ||
| *Theodore V. Grau | 1955 | *William A. Middleton | 1994 | ||
| *Dewey Beardsley,Jr. | 1956 | Wesley A. Ruppel | 1995 | ||
| *Clifford L. Tomlinson | 1957 | #Charles M. Wacker | 1996 | ||
| *George W. Patterson | 1958 | Frank G. Bender | 1997 | ||
| *Norman Kern,Jr. | 1959 | #Norman S. Clopper | 1998 | ||
| *W. Rollin Raab | 1960 | Robert E. Starke | 1999 | ||
| *John H. Connors | 1961 | Thomas M. Vasek | 2000 | ||
| *Robert F. Gruber,Sr. | 1962 | Thomas P. Murgitroyde IV | 2001 | ||
| *Richard J. Craven,Jr. | 1963 | Robert E. Starke | 2002 | ||
| *John H. Ralston Jr. - Lodge 527 | 1963 | Thomas L. Bartie | 2003 | ||
| *H. Robert Koehler - Lodge 487 | 1964 | *Joseph L. McCullough - Lodge 25 | 2003 | ||
| James W. Weimer | 1964 | Thomas P. Murgitroyde III | 2004 | ||
| *Earl P. Allabach | 1965 | *George H. Detwiler III | 2005 | ||
| Warren C. Beuttenmiller - Lodge 130 | 1965 | Jeno B. Seitz | 2006 | ||
| *Harold D. LaVoie | 1965 | Jeno B. Seitz | 2007 | ||
| *William K. Bender - Lodge 130 | 1966 | Bruce C. Cobb | 2008 | ||
| *Kenneth G. Schnell | 1966 | Bruce C. Cobb | 2009 | ||
| *William K. Bender - Lodge 130 | 1922 | Thomas M. Vasek | 2010 |
*Deceased # Resigned 1 Suspended 2 Membership Ceased
